The Cricket Inn is a great pub right on the edge of the Peak District moorland in Totley. It’s got a wonderful outside space with loads of tables and, beyond the Cricket pitch, a beautiful backdrop of the landscape.
Over the last few years, the GF offer had dwindled but it’s back and it’s really good. We called in after taking the dog for a scamper in the hills on Sunday and we had a brilliant brunch of sharing plates.
Looking at the pictures, our selection was perhaps a little protein-heavy and not so balanced.
But how could I not order salt and pepper squid with sriracha mayo when it’s coeliac-safe?
And the beef tartare came with crispy shallots. I double checked these as crispy shallots are usually bought in and sometimes a giveaway that the chef isn’t as clued up as you’d hope. But not here – they make their own! So again, a must have for me.
The scallops were from the specials menu, and were served with caramelised apple puree, celeriac and tomato consommé. An unusual pairing to my experience but it was delicious.
And the Isle of Wight tomatoes with goat’s curd had a lovely, green dressing and balanced everything out a bit.




The food arrived quickly – the service was great – it was fairly quiet at 12ish so a good time to go before the Sunday lunch crowds appear and all the tables are booked.
Apart from the small plates, the menu includes a variety of gluten free mains ranging from classics like gammon and chips, fish and chips, and steak, to some more unusual dishes like pastrami duck breast with potato and leek pave, and rose harissa roast cauliflower.
Some of their signature menu items like their pies and burgers are not available gluten free unfortunately , but there’s still enough to choose from. And if you like your chips, there is a rather fine selection, all GF: chunky, dirty, rosemary or truffle and parmesan. Price-wise, the mains range from £18 – £26.
A quick peruse of the other menus indicates a pleasing selection of dessert options as well, with a crumble and a creme brulee available as well as the ubiquitous brownie and ice cream options. Sunday roasts, I’ve not fully investigated. As usual, they’re marked GFO, which means some elements won’t be available. I can report, however, that their side of cauliflower cheese IS gluten free, which is most encouraging. Drop a comment in if you know more… A gluten free Thornbridge session IPA is available in bottles.
The Cricket Inn
Penny Lane, Sheffield S17 3AZ








